Comparison · C113

Year-end budget regime: the December spike, the quality of commitments and the rollover rule

Question addressed

Should the marketing budget be allowed to expire at year end, and on what condition does a rollover change anything?

Direct answer

An expiring budget pushes teams to commit what is left regardless of quality; allowing rollover fixes nothing while the funder reduces the next envelope by the amount carried over, and a short grace period captures most of the gain.

Decision supported

01Choose between strict expiry, full rollover and a grace period, once the funder has agreed not to cut the following envelope.

02The rule, the evidence and the next review date stay visible.

How to use this

Move from the question to the deliverable.

01Starting point

Should the marketing budget be allowed to expire at year end, and on what condition does a rollover change anything?

02Decision prepared

Choose between strict expiry, full rollover and a grace period, once the funder has agreed not to cut the following envelope.

03Deliverable to use

Weekly commitment record

Comparaison de régimes · SQ-113

Measure your own December spike, then negotiate the envelope regime

A budget that expires on 31 December creates an incentive to commit whatever is left, regardless of the quality of what is bought. The obvious remedy, allowing rollover, only works on a condition that is not in the marketing team’s hands: that the funder does not cut the next envelope by the amount carried over.

Working context

Illustrative case: an annual marketing budget of €1,110,000 committed week by week, an envelope expiring on 31 December, no rollover allowed, and a finance department that sets the next envelope from last year’s consumption.

  1. 01Measure

    Record the amount committed week by week, then divide the final week by the average of the other fifty-one. That ratio is the spike, and it compares from one year to the next.

  2. 02Qualify

    Apply to the final week’s commitments the same evidence test as to those of March. What would not pass in spring does not pass in December either.

  3. 03Settle the condition

    Ask the funder, in writing, whether the next envelope will be reduced by the amount carried over. While the answer is yes, no rollover regime changes anything.

  4. 04Choose the regime

    Take the grace period rather than full rollover: easier to obtain, and enough to rule out last-minute commitments.

Original element

Comparison of year-end budget regimes

The table starts from the spike measured over the past year, then compares three envelope regimes by what each one requires of the funder and what each actually does to the December concentration.

Calculation methodSpike = amount committed in the final week ÷ weekly average of the other fifty-one, that is €90,000 ÷ €20,000 = 4.5. Share of the year committed in the last month = €150,000 ÷ €1,110,000 = 13.5%.
Situation or regimeRollover allowedNext envelope cutFinal-week spikeWhat the funder must agree toDecision
Measured over 2025NoneNot applicable4.5 times an ordinary weekNot applicableStarting point
Strict expiry keptNoneNot applicableUnchangedNothingTo avoid
Full rollover, next envelope cut by the amountFullYesUnchangedNothing obtainableIneffective
Full rollover, next envelope independentFullNoRemovedWritten multi-year commitmentDemanding
Six-week grace periodPartialNoGreatly reducedCommitment limited to six weeksAdopted
CSV · weeks · spike · regimes · decisionsDownload the year-end regime comparison
Decision interpretation

01The measured spike is 4.5: the final week commits four and a half times an ordinary week, and the last month concentrates 13.5% of the year. That ratio is no accounting curiosity, it is the trace of an incentive, since whatever is not committed is lost.

02The most generous rollover regime can be the most useless. Liebman and Mahoney establish it: if the funder cuts the next envelope by the amount carried over, the team has no reason to carry anything over and the spike remains. The condition bears on the funder, not on the team, and it has to be settled before anything else is discussed.

03A grace period is enough. The same authors show that a rollover limited to a short window captures close to three quarters of the gain of full rollover, because it rules out the lowest-value commitments without tying up cash. It is also the easiest regime to get agreed.

04The evidence comes from elsewhere, and this page does not transfer it. Across six hundred and eighty-six United States federal IT projects and one hundred and thirty billion dollars, those committed in the final week are 2.2 to 5.6 times more likely to be poorly rated, and that week’s spending is 4.9 times the average. Nothing establishes those magnitudes for a marketing budget: the team measures its own spike, and that is the only one the decision uses.

Illustrative case. The published magnitudes concern United States federal procurement, and the authors note that theirs is the first economic analysis of the phenomenon, in government or in a firm. This page takes from them the mechanism and the rollover condition, not transferable values. The spike of 4.5 belongs to the case and is computed from its weekly record.

Coherence controls

Minimum conditions before validation.

01Consistent units

The status, the evidence and the owner must be available for review.

02Internal costs included

The status, the evidence and the owner must be available for review.

03Visible contingency

The status, the evidence and the owner must be available for review.

04Workload per period

The status, the evidence and the owner must be available for review.

Usable deliverable

Output produced

Weekly commitment record

Explore the decision further with an interactive control, or start from a structured template to produce your deliverable.